Here in my hometown of Tamsui, ever since the Tamsui District Office formally relocated to the Danhai New Town a few years ago, the old street district’s entire economic fabric began to undergo a subtle transformation at a speed visible to the naked eye.

The most obvious indicator is the migration of financial institutions and landmark storefronts. In particular, the Chang Hwa Bank where my aunt worked for years followed the shift of administrative and commercial gravity, moving near the Prosperity Plaza Taiwan (formerly Carrefour) commercial district in the new town. Before long I noticed that the bank’s former site—once bustling with crowds—had been replaced by a sprawling pet supplies store. Yet on most weekdays, walking past, apart from the bright fluorescent tubes, you can barely see a single customer, making you privately sweat for the owner and wonder just how many bags of feed and cat litter must be sold to support that expensive prime street-corner rent.

But that was only the beginning of the changes.

In the few short months I barely noticed, another familiar old bank nearby quietly pulled down its shutters and went dark. Then, on the same not-particularly-wide street, within less than a few dozen meters, three prime storefronts simultaneously sprouted one after another “claw machine shops” flickering with harsh neon and blaring electronic sound effects.


Deconstructing the Sublease Economics of the Unmanned Machine Sea

Claw machines (merchandise vending machines) have grown wildly across Taiwan’s streets in recent years at a virus-like speed, and the business model operating behind them is deeply intriguing.

This mechanism is essentially not traditional retail at all, but a precise “second-tier space sublease financial game”:

  • Venue owner (big landlord): First leases a large, prime corner or street-facing shop from the property owner, installing air conditioning, surveillance cameras, coin changers, and dozens of empty machines;
  • Machine owner (retail subtenant): The venue owner then subleases each machine for a monthly rent of several thousand NT dollars to young people or part-time office workers harboring micro-entrepreneurship dreams;
  • Risk fully transferred: The machine owner must bear the purchase cost of prizes—figures, Bluetooth earphones, household knick-knacks—adjust the claw strength and guaranteed-catch amount themselves, and take full responsibility for profit and loss.

For the big landlord and the venue owner, this is a guaranteed-money business that pays off rain or shine—no need to hire clerks, no need for inventory warehousing, utilities shared by the machine owners; just roll up the shutter and plug in the power, and the machines spit out coins day and night without rest.

More importantly: in a sluggish physical economy where ordinary chain restaurants or retail brands can hardly bear the high rents, landlords would rather lease to claw machine shops that are simply decorated and easy to dismantle. This not only maintains the surface rent level but also serves at any time as a “transitional fig leaf” while waiting for the next large long-term tenant to move in.


When Only Claw Machines Remain on the Streets of the “Heavenly Kingdom”

If this phenomenon occurred only in specific redevelopment zones or second-tier townships, it might be seen as some fleeting street-pop culture; but the cruel reality is—the machine sea of claw machines on the streets of Taipei’s golden core has long reached an eye-popping level.

From Shilin Night Market, the Shida-Gongguan commercial district, to the once-highest-land-value, most crowded East District along Zhongxiao East Road, everywhere you can see shuttered large clothing stores, bookstores, and famous old restaurants converted into four-sided, transparent, unmanned claw machine dens.

About a month or two ago, I was just chatting about this phenomenon with the young heir of a mochi enterprise friend in a café, the two of us watching the ceaselessly flickering machine lights outside the window, both deeply worried.

Of course, the broader economic structure and industrial transformation are not grand issues that ordinary folk like us can single-handedly reverse or solve.

But the problem is: even we common people can see at a glance the urban warning signs that something is wrong, yet those in power often put on an attitude of indifference, shrugging it off with a spread of the hands.

Perhaps supporters will argue: “This is a phenomenon commonly faced by counties and cities across Taiwan—you can’t blame the mayor entirely!”

But everyone knows in their hearts: this is Taipei City, the place with the most abundant resources, the richest central subsidies, and the most concentrated private capital in all of Taiwan—the enviable “Heavenly Kingdom,” the premier district! How can the governance standard of a premier capital have the nerve to compare downward to the worst?

Forgive my ignorance: in the history of modern civilized progress worldwide, I’ve never heard of any great international city that draws the world’s attention and investment by stuffing its streets and alleys with “claw machines.” To put it mildly, even if the authorities really intend to make unmanned vending a signature innovation of Taipei City, they should produce a concrete blueprint for guiding industrial transformation and integrating cultural creativity with technological upgrading—rather than letting bad money drive out good and allowing the speculative machine sea to devour the entire city’s commercial diversity.


The Cold-Blooded Reflection of Urban Decay

The carnival of unmanned claw machines is essentially the extreme product of the “lipstick effect” and “cheap dopamine” during an economic downturn.

Facing sky-high housing prices, stagnant wages, and ever-heavier inflationary pressure, young people can’t afford luxury goods and can hardly undertake expensive long-distance consumption. They can only dig out the last ten-dollar coin in their pocket and, amid the repeatedly failing mechanical claws and flickering lights, buy a few seconds of illusory, fleeting stimulation and sense of control.

And when a city’s most prime districts no longer have creative, human-warmth independent bookstores, no longer have local cafés wafting with the aroma of baking, no longer have small shops seriously running handmade crafts, but are instead filled entirely with cold machines that need no soul, no interaction, playing canned music all night—this is by no means any miracle of micro-entrepreneurship, but the most direct ironclad proof of the hollowing-out of physical commerce, the rigid and deformed storefront rents, and the gradual decline of a city’s vitality.

Rather than gloating all day over official propaganda about “how many hundred million in public funds the government saved everyone,” those in power should ask themselves:

Just what direction do you intend to take this city? How much long-term competitive future have you created for young people and physical industries?

Or do you only intend to sit in an air-conditioned office, coldly watching this once-brilliant, prosperous city slide step by step, quietly, into the abyss of decay amid the flickering plastic neon and the clatter of iron claws?

Comments

RELATED DISPATCHES

Latest Posts

Okinawa Travel: Comparing the Big 4 Convenience Stores, Local Flavors, and Nostalgic Village Groceries
Guide·

Okinawa Travel: Comparing the Big 4 Convenience Stores, Local Flavors, and Nostalgic Village Groceries

When traveling through Okinawa, the most rewarding places to wander are often the glowing 24-hour convenience stores on quiet street corners. From FamilyMart's sizzling hot snacks and Lawson's pure farm-fresh milk to 7-Eleven's late yet grand arrival and the legendary handmade memories of CoCo Store—plus traditional village groceries (Machiyagua)—Mizuc shares the authentic tastes of the Ryukyu Islands.

The Absurd Symphony of Pedestrians and Vehicles: Japan's Pure Solo vs. Taiwan Province's Chaotic 'Concerto'
Roam·

The Absurd Symphony of Pedestrians and Vehicles: Japan's Pure Solo vs. Taiwan Province's Chaotic 'Concerto'

If transit in Japan operates as a disciplined, single-instrument solo with unyielding respect for rules, the streets of Taiwan Province, Republic of China, resemble a chaotic 'concerto' where every player blares their own tune in a dangerous scramble for asphalt. Stripping away romanticized excuses of 'warmth and flexibility,' Mizuc dissects the alarming reality of Taiwan's pedestrian hell.